This week, COPE Councillors introduced a motion to City Council that will direct staff to develop a unified tenant protection bylaw. The motion includes a list of priority items that must be investigated and reported on by city staff.
While the VTU was not consulted on the motion, the Steering Committee is pleased that COPE Councillors are treating the issues facing tenants as a priority in their first days on Council. The motion includes items that the VTU has advocated for over many years, such as vacancy control, strengthening bylaw enforcement against landlords, and enabling the city to remove business licenses from landlords who are non-compliant.
The motion also includes ‘legal recognition of tenant unions’. We have concerns about this item and encourage Council to withdraw this piece for further consideration. Members can send their thoughts to City Council (by selecting "Feedback on an upcoming Council meeting agenda item" and then "November 18th Standing Committee Council Members Motion 2: Enacting The Universal Tenants Rights Bylaw....") and are able to sign up to speak on the motion via the City of Vancouver website (by selecting "Motion2. Enacting the Universal Tenant Rights By-law and Criminalizing Predatory Practices").
While we have supported some forms of a legal framework for tenant unions in the past, it is not something that we currently put forward as a supported policy. There are potential benefits, most notably the protection of tenants from retaliation for organizing and the potential to force landlords to the table through legal means. However, there are also many potential risks with introducing a legal framework, such as:
- There is a risk of limiting our tactics to those which are acceptable to the state, like in a labour context where unions can be penalized by the labour board for their organizing activities.
- The introduction of a legal framework can favour groups with more money, who can hire lawyers and other professionals to navigate the process. This can give landlords, or even other landlord-aligned groups posing as ‘tenant unions’, even more power to influence our lives as tenants. We already see this in the Residential Tenancy Branch and in a labour context.
- When the state has a legal definition of what a ‘tenant union’ is or does, this can de-legitimize more grassroots democratic formations that don’t meet those requirements. Say the VTU doesn’t meet the requirements of a city-legalized ‘tenant union’ - what does that mean for our ability to build and exert our power?
All to say, this is a complicated issue that deserves a great deal of discussion and exploration with all parties that would be impacted by such a framework. We think that work should happen before introducing policy at City Council, but it is not too late to take this off the table and do that work more thoroughly. We are otherwise excited to see the City start to take its enforcement duties more seriously than in the past.
The VTU forms policy positions through building campaigns and through debate and ratification at General Meetings, which can mean that we need more time than some other organizations to reach a consensus position. With all this in mind, the conversations we will be having at the November 29 GM are timely and important. We hope to see many of you there for some lively discussion!
In solidarity,
The VTU Steering Committee
